one (wo)man’s fugly…

is another’s omg!!! drop everything!!! i’ve GOT to knit that NOW!!! 

i think thought LOL! this sweater looks cute (especially as portrayed in the first shot, on the cover of the magazine - the very same Simply Knitting mentioned in my previous post)

SK Fug or not?

 

Still looks cute to me…

bringing up the rear - which is where it gets downright scary in my OPINION (page 18)

Bum(mer)! Only for the flat-cheeked… =:(

so what am I getting at? well, in an attempt to explore what *I* consider fugage/fuggage (do you prefer one or two g’s - anyone?) and moreover why, I present this sweater for your consideration.

at first glance I liked the color and could even embrace the dingleberries (disclosure: I own, have worn, and will wear again - fate permitting - an anthropologie sweater vest in mustard replete with said dingleberries).

but (or butt), my ‘tocks don’t need additional padding, so, the combination of dingleberries AND flaring ruffles is deadly. however, I know some ladies could make good use of the visual illusion (soooo jealous-<teeth grinding>).

i also know that the sweater can be modified, etc. etc. etc.

why THIS sweater (wtf?): well, when whatnottoknit gave me the greenlight as a contributor, I began looking for fuggage (I think two g’s look better) in my stash while standing next to my DH, who without hesitation, nominated said sweater.

his reasoning:

  • brown/blue color scheme (I countered that this is *in* and besides, the tank top/shirt doesn’t count when determining fugliness)
  • the bell sleeves which “date to the American revolution”
  • the ribbon tie - “looks infantile, too precious”
  • the dingleberries (he’s forgotting that I wear dingleberries); and last, but not least…
  • the flaring ruffles covering the model’s backside (here we had reached a consensus)

will I ever knit this sweater? your guess is as good as mine!

pass the Corona - cheers! = ;)

~firesheep67

10 Responses to “one (wo)man’s fugly…”

  1. PepperjackCandy Says:

    This looks like a costume for the old Dark Shadows TV series to me — kind of a 1960/1970s version of something from the turn of the previous century. Just replace the current model with Lara Parker and we’d be all set!

    Not sure if that means I like it or not, though . . .

  2. Tephra Says:

    I’d probably knit it, swapping out the bobbles for a lace motif or something, and ditching the ribbon (which looks out of scale and far too precious).

  3. Double Take Says:

    I don’t know… I don’t know… Each thing separate is okay, but put together, like my son would say, “It’s just wrong, Mom, it’s just wrong!”

  4. lolarusa Says:

    Dingleberries are fine for kleenex covers, but should never be worn on one’s person. Except for you, firesheep. They look great on you.

  5. catsmum Says:

    the ruffled cuffs would be okay on an otherwise plain cardi but with the addition of the dingleberries SO NOT.
    The ribbon - I always think it looks like the designer copped out on coming up with a proper closure plus, yeah, too precious
    The bum rufflage ? well unless one is built like Kate Moss or Mrs Beckham, again so NOT the way I want to see anyone.
    Nice colour but a prime example of trying to put too many ideas into one garment. Whatever happened to the KISS principle?

  6. whatnottocrochet Says:

    Even the front is a little suspect with those boil bobbles sticking out of her sleeves.

  7. Maryann Says:

    I disagree with you regarding what makes this a fug. It’s just one word: bobbles. You thought they were cute. I think they look cancerous.

  8. Crafty Nature Says:

    I hate the color and this thing would make my butt look big. Maybe in cream or pink, but other than that I like it.

  9. ketutar Says:

    ROTFLMAO!!! I was peacefully scrolling down, saw her face, shoulders, armbows, and thought it doesn’t look bad at all… and then I saw the thing below the breastline… Oh, yes, it DOES look bad. LOL

  10. Mira Says:

    It’s just ugly. I hate those froofy sweaters I’m always finding patterns for at the yarn store. What puts it over the edge is the ribbon, I think.

Leave a Reply